402
edits
Important: The GCConnex decommission will not affect GCCollab or GCWiki. Thank you and happy collaborating!
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 138:
Line 138: − + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Annual Report to Parliament for the 2017 to 2018 Fiscal Year: Federal Regulatory Management Initiatives (view source)
Revision as of 13:54, 28 July 2022
, 13:54, 28 July 2022no edit summary
* 166 were low-impact (90.2% of GIC regulations and 56.8% of all regulations)
* 166 were low-impact (90.2% of GIC regulations and 56.8% of all regulations)
* 18 were significant (9.8% of GIC regulations and 6.2% of all regulations)
* 18 were significant (9.8% of GIC regulations and 6.2% of all regulations
[[File:20181127-01-eng.png|left|thumb|'''Figure 1: overview of regulations approved and published in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year''']]
<blockquote><blockquote style="background-color: white; border: solid thin grey;">Figure 1 provides an overview of the categories of regulations approved and published in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year.
During this period, 108 non-Governor in Council regulations were published, and 184 Governor in Council regulations were published.
Of the 184 Governor in Council regulations, 166 were low-impact regulations, and 18 were medium- or high-impact regulations, also known as significant regulations.
Of the 18 significant regulations, 15 had a cost-benefit analysis of monetized costs and benefits, two had an analysis of monetized costs only, and one had quantified costs and benefits.</blockquote></blockquote>
=== Qualitative benefits and costs ===
The most basic element of any analysis of costs and benefits is a text description of the expected impacts associated with the regulatory proposal. This description is referred to as qualitative analysis and is used to:
* provide decision-makers with an evidence-based understanding of the anticipated impacts of the regulation
* provide context for further analysis that is expressed in numerical or monetary terms
Qualitative analysis should be part of every CBA. Regulators are required to describe the expected impacts of the proposal in qualitative terms, including for low-impact proposals, as this qualitative information supports the basis for decision-making.
The following are examples of qualitative impacts identified in significant regulations in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year:
* “The emission reductions realized…will lead to improvements in air quality and in associated health benefits to Canadians.”
* “Bilateral relations with key trading partners (Brazil and the European Union) will be improved as visa screening shifts towards screening tailored to individual risk.”
* “Continuance of the Government’s commitment and leadership to help support the well-being of veterans and their families.”
=== Quantitative benefits and costs ===
Quantitative benefits and costs are those that are described as a measurement. Examples of quantitative information are:
* the number of recipients of a benefit
* the amount of pollution reduced
* the amount of time saved
As is the case with qualitative information, quantitative benefits and costs can be used in two ways:
* on their own, they illustrate the expected magnitude of a proposal by providing measurable figures to decision-makers
* they can be used as a factor in developing cost estimates
Quantitative analysis is an element of all significant proposals. It provides key metrics on the frequency or number of instances of an activity, and is essential for the development of benefit and cost estimates. It can also be used on its own alongside qualitative information to illustrate the overall impact of a proposal in non-monetary terms. Although quantitative analysis is not required for low-impact proposals, it is often included alongside qualitative information to provide information that is useful to decision-makers.
The following are examples of quantified benefits and costs identified in significant regulations in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year:
* measures introduced under the ''[http://gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-10-04/html/sor-dors196-eng.html Regulations Amending the Off-Road Small Spark-Ignition Engine Emission Regulations and Making a Consequential Amendment to Another Regulation]'' will reduce emissions of nitrogen oxides (NO2) by 20,000 tonnes between 2019 and 2032
* the ''[http://gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-07-12/html/sor-dors126-eng.html Regulations Amending the Canada Student Financial Assistance Regulations]'' will result in 12,623 more students per year being able to pursue training as skilled workers
* changes under the ''[http://gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-04-05/html/sor-dors42-eng.html Regulations Amending the Canadian Forces Members and Veterans Re-establishment and Compensation Regulations]'' are expected to benefit up to 615 eligible recipients of rehabilitation services and vocational assistance from 2017 to 2027
=== Monetized benefits and costs ===
Monetized benefits and costs are those that are expressed in a currency amount, such as dollars, using an approach that considers both the value of an impact and when it occurs.<ref>The Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat recommends that present values be estimated using a 7% discount rate. This rate is based on a weighted average of foreign and domestic sources of capital funding for projects in the private sector. In some cases, benefits and costs may occur in areas that do not crowd out or create private investment. In such cases, a lower discount rate, the social discount rate, of 3% may be appropriate.</ref>
An analysis of monetized costs and benefits is required for all high-impact regulatory proposals. Medium-impact proposals must always include monetized costs, although benefits may be expressed quantitatively or qualitatively when data are not readily available. Most regulatory proposals that are medium- and high-impact typically include both monetized benefits and costs as part of the analysis.
In order for costs and benefits to be considered monetized, the dollar values used in a CBA are adjusted so that values and prices that occur at different times are equal:
* to their exchange value (inflation adjustment)
* when they occur (discounting)
Of the 18 significant regulations finalized in the 2017 to 2018 year, 17 had monetized impacts, representing 9.2% of GIC regulations and 5.8% of all regulations. Of these:
* 15 had monetized benefits and costs
* 2 had monetized costs only
* 1 had quantified costs and benefits
[[File:20181127-02-eng.png|left|thumb|'''Figure 2: net benefits and costs, 2017 to 2018 fiscal year''']]
<blockquote style="background-color: white; border: solid thin grey;">Figure 2 depicts the net benefit of significant regulations published during the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year.
The total cost associated with significant regulations was $4.4 billion.
The total benefit associated with significant regulations was $8.5 billion.
The difference between the total cost and total benefit is a net benefit of $4.1 billion.</blockquote>Of the 15 regulations that had monetized estimates of both benefits and costs (expressed as total present value):<ref>To remove the effect of inflation, figures are expressed in 2012 dollars and, as such, will vary from those published in the RIASs.</ref>
* total costs were $4,429,808,584
* total benefits were $8,533,837,575
* net benefits were $4,104,028,991
The following are examples of monetized benefits and costs identified in regulations in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year:
* The ''[http://www.gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-10-18/html/sor-dors216-eng.html Regulations Amending the Ozone-Depleting Substances and Halocarbon Alternatives Regulations]'' aim to avert future hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) releases to the environment by reducing:
** the supply of HFCs that enter into Canada
** the demand for HFCs in manufactured products Such reductions will:
** decrease Canada’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions
** help limit increases in global average temperatures
** contribute to Canada’s international obligations to combat climate change Additionally, the amendments enabled Canada to ratify and implement the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol. The cumulative net benefit associated with the measures in this regulation is estimated at $3.725 billion (net present value) from 2018 to 2040.
* The ''[http://gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-05-03/html/sor-dors53-eng.html Regulations Amending the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations]'' expand electronic travel authorization eligibility to travellers from Brazil, Bulgaria and Romania who have held a Canadian temporary resident visa at any time during the last 10 years, or who, at the time of application, hold a valid non-immigrant visa from the US. The amendments also enable a new immigration information-sharing connection with the US to confirm the validity of a visa issued by the other country. The cumulative net benefit associated with the measures in this regulation is estimated at $115.3 million from 2017 to 2026.
* The ''[http://gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-10-04/html/sor-dors196-eng.html Regulations Amending the Off-Road Small Spark-Ignition Engine Emission Regulations and Making a Consequential Amendment to Another Regulatio]n'' will reduce smog caused by air pollutant emissions from small spark-ignition (SSI) engines, which has a significant adverse impact on the health and environment of Canadians and, as a result, on the Canadian economy. In addition to providing important health and environmental benefits, the amendments aim to:
** restore common Canada-US standards for air pollutant emissions from SSI engines
** contribute to minimizing the administrative burden costs incurred by companies importing these engines into Canada The estimated net benefit of the changes is $107.6 million (net present value) from 2019 to 2032.
The purpose of CBA is to demonstrate that the expected benefits of a proposal are greater than the expected costs. This determination, however, is not based entirely on monetized benefits and costs. CBAs frequently include quantitative and qualitative analysis in addition to monetized analysis, and the overall analysis must consider this broader range of evidence. In the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year:
* three regulatory proposals had monetized costs that were equal to monetized benefits, which is usually associated with a direct transfer from one party to another
* three regulatory proposals had monetized costs that were greater than monetized benefits
For detailed benefits and costs by regulation, see <u>'''Appendix A.'''</u>
== Section 2: implementation of the one-for-one rule ==
=== The one-for-one rule ===
In order to comply with the annual reporting requirements of the ''[http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/R-4.5/page-1.html Red Tape Reduction Act]'', this report also provides an update on the implementation of the one-for-one rule.
The one-for-one rule, instituted in the 2012 to 2013 fiscal year, seeks to control the growth of administrative burden on business that arises from regulations. When a new or amended regulation increases the administrative burden on business, the rule requires that the cost of this burden be offset via other regulatory changes. Administrative burden includes:
* planning, collecting, processing and reporting of information
* completing forms
* retaining data required by the federal government to comply with a regulation
The rule also requires that an existing regulation be repealed each time a new regulation imposes new administrative burden on business.
The rule applies to all regulatory changes that impose new administrative burden costs on business. There are three categories of exemptions established under the ''Red Tape Reduction Act'':
# regulations related to tax or tax administration
# regulations where there is no discretion regarding what is to be included in the regulation (for example, treaty obligations or the implementation of a court decision)
# regulations made in response to an emergency or other unique circumstance where compliance with the rule would compromise the Canadian economy, public health or safety
Regulators are required to monetize and report on:
* the change in administrative burden
* feedback from stakeholders and Canadians on regulators’ estimates of administrative burden costs or savings to business
* the number of regulations created or removed
As with CBA, the dollar values used in estimates of administrative burden are adjusted so that values and prices that occur at different times are equal in their exchange value (inflation adjustment) and when they occur (discounting). In this report, all figures related to the one-for-one rule are expressed in 2012 dollars to permit meaningful and consistent comparison of regulations, regardless of the fiscal year in which they were introduced.
In 2015, the ''Red Tape Reduction Act'' enshrined the existing policy requirement for the one-for-one rule in law. Section 9 of the ''Red Tape Reduction Act'' requires that the President of the Treasury Board prepare and make public an annual report on the application of the rule.
The ''Red Tape Reduction Regulations'' state that the following must be included in the annual report:
* a summary of the increases and decreases in the cost of administrative burden that results from regulatory changes that are made in accordance with section 5 of the act within the 12-month period ending on March 31 of the year in which the report is made public
* the number of regulations that are amended or repealed as a result of regulatory changes that are made in accordance with section 5 of the act within that 12-month period
=== Key findings on the implementation of the one-for-one rule ===
The main findings on changes in administrative regulatory burden and the overall number of regulations for the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year are as follows:
* administrative burden reductions of $71,395 per year were achieved in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year, resulting in approximately $30.3 million reduced since the 2012 to 2013 fiscal year
* 85 regulatory titles (net) were taken off the books, with a total net reduction of 131 titles since the 2012 to 2013 fiscal year
A detailed report on regulations that had implications under the one-for-one rule is in '''<u>Appendix B.</u>'''
The regulations that removed the most regulatory burden in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year were the [http://gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2017/2017-10-04/html/sor-dors196-eng.html ''Regulations Amending the Off-Road Small Spark-Ignition Engine Emission Regulations and Making a Consequential Amendment to Another Regulation''.] These regulations reduced administrative burden on businesses by $169,541 per year by:
* shifting from per-shipment to annual submission of importation declarations for companies importing fewer than 500 SSI engines into Canada per year
* eliminating the requirement altogether for companies that import fewer than 50 SSI engines per year
The Treasury Board monitors regulators’ compliance with the requirement to offset administrative burden and titles imposed on business through regulatory changes:
* System-wide, the federal government remains in compliance with the requirement in the ''Red Tape Reduction Act'' to offset administrative burden and titles within 24 months.
* The Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat also tracks offsetting requirements by portfolio, and the Fisheries and Oceans portfolio currently has an outstanding balance of $258,490, related primarily to the ''Aquaculture Activities Regulations'', which were introduced June 28, 2015. Officials from the Secretariat and Fisheries and Oceans Canada continue to work together to identify offsets that will balance the account.
[[File:20181127-03-eng.png|left|thumb|'''Figure 3: overview of the findings on the one-for-one rule for the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year''']]
<blockquote style="background-color: white; border: solid thin grey;">Figure 3 provides statistics on the implementation of the one-for-one rule for significant regulations published in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year.
There was one new regulatory title added to the regulatory stock and 86 regulatory titles repealed, for a net of 85 fewer regulations in the regulatory stock.
There were 10 instances where regulations were exempted from the one-for-one rule, including seven emergency or crisis situations, zero exemptions for tax and tax administration, and three non-discretionary obligations.
In total, 11 regulations increased administrative burden by $314,485, and 8 regulations decreased administrative burden by $385,880, for a net reduction of $71,395 in administrative burden costs.</blockquote>
== Section 3: update on the Administrative Burden Baseline ==
=== The Administrative Burden Baseline ===
The Administrative Burden Baseline (ABB) provides Canadians with a count of the total number of administrative requirements in federal regulations (GIC and non-GIC) and associated forms.
The ABB was first publicly reported on in September 2014, providing a baseline count of administrative requirements by regulator. Since then, regulators continue to:
* re-examine the count of their administrative requirements occurring from July 1 to June 30 each year
* publicly post updates to their ABB count by September 30 each year
=== Key findings on the Administrative Burden Baseline ===
The baseline provides Canadians with information on 38 regulators.
As of June 30, 2017:
* the total number of administrative requirements was 136,121, a reduction of 458 from the 2016 count of 136,579
* there were 580 regulations identified by regulators as having administrative requirements, a reduction of 19 from the 2016 figure of 599
* the average number of administrative requirements per regulation was 235, up from the 2016 average of 228
The top three changes in the ABB in 2017 were:
# There were 344 fewer net administrative requirements for Health Canada, related mainly to the replacement of the ''Marihuana for Medical Purposes Regulations'' (SOR/2013-199) with the Access to ''Cannabis for Medical Purposes Regulations'' (SOR/2016-230).
# A net increase of 167 administrative requirements for the Canadian Food Inspection Agency related mainly to changes to the ''Health of Animals Regulations (Import Reference Document)''.
# A net increase of 153 administrative requirements for Transport Canada associated with amendments to the following cumulatively added 279 administrative requirements:
#* ''Regulations Amending the Canadian Aviation Regulations (Aerodrome Work Consultations)''
#* ''Locomotive Emissions Regulations''
#* ''Marine Liability and Information Return Regulations''
#* ''Prevention and Control of Fires on Line Works Regulations''
#* ''Vessel Fire Safety Regulations'' However, the ''Order Repealing Certain Regulations'' Made Under the ''Railway Safety Act'' removed 126 administrative requirements.
A detailed summary of the ABB count for 2017 and for previous years is in '''<u>Appendix B.</u>'''
== Section 4: looking forward: the ''Cabinet Directive on Regulation'' ==
=== Overview ===
On September 1, 2018, the ''Cabinet Directive on Regulation'' came into effect, replacing the ''Cabinet Directive on Regulatory Management'' as the policy for the regulation-making process.
The new directive updates Canada’s regulatory policy and is based on three broad concepts:
# emphasis on the regulatory life-cycle approach
# reinforcing good regulatory practices in the regulatory development process (consultation, transparency and CBA)
# alignment of the directive with government priorities such as regulatory cooperation, gender-based analysis, environmental impact assessment and Indigenous-Crown consultation, as well as requiring periodic reviews of the stock of regulations
Because this report covers the period of April 1, 2017, to March 31, 2018, it covers regulations that were developed and finalized under the former ''Cabinet Directive on Regulatory Management''.
=== Policies supporting the new directive ===
The ''Cabinet Directive on Regulation'' is supported by a new suite of policies that regulators must follow as they develop proposed regulations. These policies include the following:
* ''Policy on Regulatory Development'': The ''Policy on Regulatory Development'' outlines the requirements and process for regulators when developing and bringing forward a draft regulation to the GIC:
** the policy maintains consultation and engagement requirements throughout the regulatory development process
** the policy also sets out renewed Regulatory Impact Analysis requirements for draft regulations, including adding regulatory cooperation, gender-based analysis plus and environmental impact lenses
* ''Policy on Cost-Benefit Analysis'': The ''Policy on Cost-Benefit Analysis'' represents the first time that CBA requirements for Canadian regulations are enshrined in policy. The policy outlines overarching mandatory requirements for analyzing the benefits and costs of proposed regulations:
** it requires both robust analysis and public transparency, including:
*** reporting stakeholder consultations on CBA in the RIAS
*** making the CBA available publicly
** regulators are now required to monetize both benefits and costs of all significant regulations (high- and medium-impact), which previously had been mandatory for high-impact regulations only
* ''Policy on Limiting Regulatory Burden on Business'': The ''Policy on Limiting Regulatory Burden'' sets out the requirements for the one-for-one rule and the small business lens:
** the one-for-one rule is established by the Red Tape Reduction Act and the Red Tape Reduction Regulations, and the policy sets out the operational details related to the rule’s application
** the small business lens will now apply to all regulatory proposals, thereby contributing to a more systematic consideration of small business impacts in federal regulations
* ''Policy on Regulatory Transparency and Accountability'': The ''Policy on Regulatory Transparency and Accountability'' modernizes requirements for government-wide initiatives that contribute to the openness of the regulatory system:
** forward regulatory plans will be updated more frequently, with increased transparency on:
*** regulatory cooperation
*** expected impacts
*** upcoming regulatory reviews
*** access to supporting analysis in order to provide better predictability
** service standards will be developed for high-volume regulatory transactions affecting any regulated party to:
*** promote timeliness of decision-making
*** provide clear information on expectations for interactions and service
** policies on providing guidance on regulatory requirements (formerly “interpretation policies”) will continue to be published to explain how regulators help regulated parties understand their regulatory obligations
== Appendix A: detailed report on cost-benefit analyses for the 2017-2018 fiscal year<ref>Figures are taken from the RIAS in final federal regulations published in the ''Canada Gazette'', Part II, in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year. To remove the effect of inflation, figures are expressed in 2012 dollars and vary from those published in the RIAS, permitting meaningful and consistent comparison, regardless of the year in which outcomes were originally measured.</ref> ==
Table A1 indicates significant proposals that included both '''monetized''' benefits and '''monetized''' costs. These proposals may also include quantitative and/or qualitative CBA data to supplement the monetized CBA.
=== Table A1: final significant regulatory changes in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year that had monetized benefits and costs ===
{| class="wikitable"
!Department
!Regulation
!Benefits (total present value)
!Costs (total present value)
!Net present value
|-
! colspan="5" |'''High-impact regulations'''
|-
!Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Canada Grain Regulations'' (SOR/2017-125)
|$67,210,107
|$67,210,107
|$0
|-
!Employment and Social Development Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Canada Student Financial Assistance Regulations'' (SOR/ 2017-126)
|$1,380,199,234
|$1,292,537,931
|$87,661,303
|-
!Employment and Social Development Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Canada Student Financial Assistance Regulations'' (SOR/ 2018-31)
Note: CBA included in ''Regulations Amending the Apprentice Loans Regulations'' (SOR/2017-32)
|$592,450,641
|$577,776,940
|$14,673,700
|-
!Environment and Climate Change Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Ozone-Depleting Substances and Halocarbon Alternatives Regulations'' (SOR/2017-216)
Note: CBA included in ''Regulations Amending the Regulations Designating Regulatory Provisions for Purposes of Enforcement (Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999)'' (SOR/2017-217)
|$5,818,285,824
|$2,092,680,460
|$3,725,605,364
|-
!Transport Canada
|''Locomotive Emissions Regulations'' (SOR/2017-121)
|$244,950,000
|$162,310,000
|$82,640,000
|-
! colspan="5" |Medium-impact regulations
|-
!Environment and Climate Change Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Off-Road Small Spark-Ignition Engine Emission Regulations and Making a Consequential Amendment to Another Regulation'' (SOR/2017-196)
|$194,204,160
|$86,556,020
|$107,648,140
|-
!Great Lakes Pilotage Authority
|''Regulations Amending the Great Lakes Pilotage Tariff Regulations'' (SOR/2017-105)
|$22,479,594
|$5,541,595
|$16,937,998
|-
!Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations'' (SOR/ 2017-53)
|$126,549,349
|$11,284,061
|$115,265,287
|-
!Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations'' (SOR/2017-246)
|$7,740,307
|$39,680,728
| -$31,940,421
|-
!Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations'' (SOR/2017-279)
|$26,391,648
|$26,391,648
|$0
|-
!Pacific Pilotage Authority
|''Regulations Amending the Pacific Pilotage Tariff Regulations'' (SOR/2017-83)
|$15,953,665
|$15,953,665
|$0
|-
!Veterans Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Canadian Forces Members and Veterans Re-establishment and Compensation Regulations'' (SOR/2017-42)
|$10,471,860
|$11,132,248
| -$660,388
|-
!Veterans Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Canadian Forces Members and Veterans Re-establishment and Compensation Regulations'' (SOR/2017-161)
|$26,951,188
|$40,753,180
| -$13,801,992
|-
! colspan="2" |Total
|$8,533,837,575
|$4,429,808,583
|$4,104,028,991
|}
Table A2 indicates a medium-impact proposal that included '''monetized''' costs and '''quantified''' benefits. Monetized costs are required for all significant proposals; however, a medium-impact proposal may express '''benefits''' in quantitative or quantitative terms in situations where it is impractical to monetize those benefits.
=== Table A2: final regulatory changes in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year that had monetized costs and quantified benefits ===
{| class="wikitable"
!Department
!Regulation
!Costs (total present value)
|-
! colspan="3" |Medium-impact regulations
|-
!Health Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Food and Drug Regulations (Veterinary Drugs: Antimicrobial Resistance)'' (SOR/2017-76)
Note: CBA included in ''Regulations Amending the Establishment Licensing Fees (Veterinary Drugs) Regulations'' (SOR/2017-77)
|$39,486,039
|-
! colspan="2" |Total
|$39,486,039
|}
Table A3 indicates a significant proposal for which quantified benefits and costs were provided.
=== Table A3: list of final significant regulatory changes in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year that had quantified benefits and quantified costs ===
{| class="wikitable"
!Department
!Regulation
|-
!Transport Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Motor Vehicle Safety Regulations (Electronic Stability Control Systems for Heavy Vehicles)'' (SOR/2017-104)
|}
== Appendix B: detailed report on the one-for-one rule for the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year ==
=== Table B1: final regulatory changes in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year that had administrative burden implications under the one-for-one rule and published in the ''Canada Gazette'', Part II ===
{| class="wikitable"
!Portfolio
!Regulation
!Publication date
!Net burden in
!Net burden out
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Certain Regulations Made Under Sections 140, 209 and 286.1 of the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999'' (SOR/2017-110)
|June 14, 2017
|$0
|$68,265
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Wild Animal and Plant Trade Regulations'' (SOR/2017-123)
|June 28, 2017
|$10,429
|$0
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Off-Road Small Spark-Ignition Engine Emission Regulations and Making a Consequential Amendment to Another Regulation'' (SOR/2017-196)
|October 4, 2017
|$0
|$169,541
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Ozone-Depleting Substances and Halocarbon Alternatives Regulations'' (SOR/2017-216)
|October 18, 2017
|$0
|$1,100
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Order Amending Schedule 1 to the Species at Risk Act'' (SOR/2017-229)
|November 15, 2017
|$6,490
|$0
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Order Amending Schedule 1 to the Species at Risk Act'' (SOR/2018-10)
|February 21, 2018
|$58
|$0
|-
|'''Environment and Climate Change Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending Certain Regulations Made Under Section 89, Subsection 93(1) and Section 114 of the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999'' (SOR/2018-11)
|February 21, 2018
|$0
|$120,534
|-
|'''Fisheries and Oceans Canada'''
|''Regulations Repealing the Fish Health Protection Regulations'' (SOR/2017-122)
|June 28, 2017
|$0
|$4,466
|-
|'''Health Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Food and Drug Regulations (Part G: Methylphenidate)'' (SOR/2017-43)
|April 5, 2017
|$4,080
|$0
|-
|'''Health Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Food and Drug Regulations (Veterinary Drugs: Antimicrobial Resistance)'' (SOR/2017-76)
|May 17, 2017
|$253,011
|$0
|-
|'''Health Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Food and Drug Regulations (Importation of Drugs for an Urgent Public Health Need'') (SOR/2017-133)
|July 12, 2017
|$589
|$0
|-
|'''Health Canada'''
|''Order Amending Schedule III to the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (Aminorex)'' (SOR/2017-249)
|December 13, 2017
|$280
|$0
|-
|'''Health Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Fees in Respect of Drugs and Medical Devices Regulations (DIN Requirements for Drugs Listed in Schedule C to the Food and Drugs Act That Are in Dosage Form)'' (SOR/2017-260)
|December 13, 2017
|$13,885
|$0
|-
|'''Health Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Narcotic Control Regulations and the New Classes of Practitioners Regulations (Diacetylmorphine (Heroin) and Methadone)'' (SOR/2018-37)
|March 21, 2018
|$0
|$21,920
|-
|'''Transport Canada'''
|''Locomotive Emissions Regulations'' (SOR/2017-121)
|June 28, 2017
|$21,637
|$0
|-
|'''Transport Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Regulations (International Harmonization Update, 2016)'' (SOR/2017-137)
|July 2, 2017
|$4,026
|$0
|-
|'''Transport Canada'''
|''Regulations Amending the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Regulations (Marine Provisions)'' (SOR/2017-253)
|December 13, 2017
|$0
|$54
|-
! colspan="3" |Total
|$314,485
|$385,880
|-
! colspan="3" |Net administrative burden for the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year
| colspan="2" |($71,395)
|}
=== Table 2: new regulatory titles and repealed regulations in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!Portfolio
!Regulation
!Net impact
on regulatory stock
|-
| colspan="3" |'''New regulatory titles that have administrative burden'''
|-
!Transport Canada
|''Locomotive Emissions Regulations'' (SOR/2017-121)
|1
|-
| colspan="2" |'''Subtotal'''
|1
|-
| colspan="3" |'''Repealed regulations'''
|-
!Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
|''Regulations Repealing the Certain Regulations Under the Farm Income Protection Act (Miscellaneous Program) (SOR/2017-84)'' repealed:
* ''Wheat Stabilization 1977 Regulations'' (SOR/79-108)
* ''Greenhouse Cucumber Stabilization Regulations, 1979'' (SOR/80-587)
* ''Yellow Seed Onion Stabilization 1978 Regulations'' (SOR/80-167)
* ''Western Grain Stabilization Regulations'' (C.R.C., c. 1607)
* ''Protection for the Income of Milk Producers Regulations (1996)'' (SOR/96-295)
* ''Protection for the Income of Milk Producers Regulations (1995-2)'' (SOR/95-295)
* ''Protection for the Income of Milk Producers Regulations (1995-1)'' (SOR/95-294)
* ''Protection for the Income of Milk Producers Regulations (1994)'' (SOR/94-463)
* ''Protection for the Income of Milk Producers Regulations (1993-2)'' (SOR/93-313)
* ''Pear Stabilization Regulations, 1982'' (SOR/83-606)
* ''Yellow Seed Onions Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-23)
* ''Potato Stabilization Regulations, 1977'' (SOR/78-445)
* ''Yellow Seed Onion Stabilization 1977 Regulations'' (SOR/79-276)
* ''Winter Wheat Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-20)
* ''Winter Pears Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/78-136)
* ''White Pea Bean Stabilization Regulations, 1985-86'' (SOR/87-286)
* ''White Pea Bean Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-26)
* ''White Pea Bean Stabilization 1977 Regulations'' (SOR/78-609)
* ''Sheep Stabilization 1981 Regulations'' (SOR/82-494)
* ''Protection for the Income of Milk Producers Regulations (1993-1)'' (SOR/93-312)
* ''Sweet Cherry Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/78-151)
* ''Sugar Beet Stabilization Regulations, 1977'' (SOR/79-379)
* ''British Columbia Peach Stabilization Regulations, 1983'' (SOR/85-1034)
* ''British Columbia Peach Stabilization Regulations, 1987'' (SOR/88-591)
* ''British Columbia Pear Stabilization Regulations, 1983-84'' (SOR/85-1033)
* ''British Columbia Pear Stabilization Regulations, 1987'' (SOR/88-592)
* ''Cabbage Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-27)
* ''British Columbia Prunes Stabilization Regulations, 1987'' (SOR/88-593)
* ''Sugar Beet Stabilization Regulations, 1986'' (SOR/87-278)
* ''Sugar Beet Stabilization Regulations, 1985'' (SOR/86-28)
* ''British Columbia Prune-Plum Stabilization Regulations, 1983'' (SOR/85-1035)
* ''Sugar Beet Stabilization Regulations, 1981'' (SOR/83-736)
* ''Corn Stabilization Regulations, 1977-78'' (SOR/79-476)
* ''Sour Cherry Stabilization Regulations, 1987'' (SOR/88-381)
* ''Oats 1987 Period Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/89-132)
* ''Sour Cherry Stabilization Regulations, 1980'' (SOR/82-17)
* ''White Pea Bean Stabilization 1978 Regulations'' (SOR/80-76)
* ''Rutabaga Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-25)
* ''Prune Stabilization Regulations, 1982'' (SOR/83-608)
* ''Potato Stabilization Regulations, 1979'' (SOR/81-295)
* ''Potato Stabilization Regulations, 1978'' (SOR/80-55)
* ''Sugar Beet Stabilization Regulations, 1982'' (SOR/84-665)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream 1989 Period Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/89-265)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1984-85 Regulations'' (SOR/84-394)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1983-84 Regulations'' (SOR/83-581)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1982-83 Regulations'' (SOR/82-996)
* ''Cheese Stabilization Regulations, 1979-80'' (SOR/80-82)
* ''Corn 1987 Period Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/89-131)
* ''Greenhouse Cucumber Stabilization Regulations, 1981'' (SOR/83-201)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1985-86 Regulations'' (SOR/85-546)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1986-87 Regulations'' (SOR/86-687)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1981-82 Regulations'' (SOR/81-456)
* ''Hog Stabilization Regulations, 1983-84'' (SOR/84-707)
* ''Hog Stabilization 1980-81 Regulations'' (SOR/81-609)
* ''Hog Stabilization 1979-80 Regulations'' (SOR/80-515)
* ''Greenhouse Tomato Stabilization Regulations, 1981'' (SOR/83-188)
* ''Greenhouse Cucumber Stabilization Regulations, 1982'' (SOR/84-22)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1980-81 Regulations'' (SOR/80-336)
* ''Sour Cherry Stabilization Regulations, 1982'' (SOR/83-214)
* ''Cheese Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/82-995)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1979-80 Regulations'' (SOR/79-477)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1978-79 Regulations'' (SOR/78-509)
* ''Cheese Stabilization Regulations, 1984-85'' (SOR/84-383)
* ''Cheese Stabilization Regulations, 1983-84'' (SOR/83-674)
* ''Cheese Stabilization Regulations, 1981-82'' (SOR/81-745)
* ''Coloured Bean Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-708)
* ''Cheese Stabilization 1980-81 Regulations'' (SOR/81-375)
* ''Carrot Stabilization Regulations, 1982-83'' (SOR/84-24)
* ''Canola Stabilization Regulations, 1986'' (SOR/88-379)
* ''Canola 1989 Period Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/91-243)
* ''Canola 1988 Period Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/91-242)
* ''Canola 1987 Period Stabilization Regulations'' (SOR/89-134)
* ''Industrial Milk and Cream Stabilization 1988-89 Regulations'' (SOR/88-318)
* ''Greenhouse Cucumber Stabilization Regulations, 1980'' (SOR/82-16)
|(74)
|-
!Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
|''Regulations Amending and Repealing Certain Canadian Food Inspection Agency Regulations (Miscellaneous Program)'' (SOR/2017-94) repealed:
* ''Phytophthora Ramorum Compensation Regulations'' (SOR/2007-135)
|(1)
|-
!Employment and Social Development Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Canada Pension Plan Regulations and Repealing the Canada Pension Plan (Social Insurance Numbers) Regulations'' (SOR/2017-120) repealed:
* ''Canada Pension Plan (Social Insurance Numbers) Regulations'' (C.R.C., c. 386)
|(1)
|-
!Fisheries and Oceans Canada
|''Regulations Repealing the Fish Health Protection Regulations'' (SOR/2017-122) repealed:
* ''Fish Health Protection Regulations'' (C.R.C., c. 812)
|(1)
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Repealing the United Nations Côte d'Ivoire Regulations'' (SOR/2017-54) repealed:
* ''United Nations Côte d'Ivoire Regulations'' (SOR/2005-127)
|(1)
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Repealing the Regulations Implementing the United Nations Resolutions on Liberia'' (SOR/2017-55) repealed:
* ''Regulations Implementing the United Nations Resolutions on Liberia'' (SOR/2001-261'')''
|(1)
|-
!Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Repealing the Certain Regulations Made Under the Arctic Waters Pollution Prevention Act (Miscellaneous Program)'' (SOR/2017-135) repealed:
* ''Arctic Waters Experimental Pollution Regulations, 1978'' (SOR/78-417)
* ''Arctic Waters Experimental Pollution Regulations, 1979'' (SOR/80-9)
* ''Arctic Waters Experimental Pollution Regulations, 1982'' (SOR/82-276)
* ''Arctic Waters Experimental Pollution Regulations, 1982 (Dome Petroleum)'' (SOR/82-832)
|(4)
|-
!Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada
|''Regulations Repealing the Canada Corporations Regulations'' (SOR/2017-283) repealed:
* ''Canada Corporations Regulations'' (C.R.C., c. 424)
|(1)
|-
!Public Services and Procurement Canada
|''Regulations Amending and Repealing Certain Regulations Made Under the Public Service Employment Act'' (SOR/2017-252) repealed:
* ''Regulations on the Employment with Statistics Canada for the Purpose of the 2006 Census'' (SOR/2004-257)
* ''Statistics Canada 1996 Census of Population Terms Regulations'' (SOR/95-153b)
|(2)
|-
! colspan="2" |Subtotal
|(86)
|-
| colspan="3" |'''New regulations that simultaneously repealed and replaced existing regulations'''
|-
!Transport Canada
|''Arctic Shipping Safety and Pollution Prevention Regulations (SOR/2017-286)'' replaced the ''Arctic Shipping Pollution Prevention Regulations'' (C.R.C., c. 353)
|0
|-
| colspan="2" |'''Subtotal'''
|0
|-
| colspan="2" |'''Total net impact on regulatory stock for the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year'''
|85
|}
=== Table B3: regulatory changes exempted from the one-for-one rule and published in the ''Canada Gazette'', Part II, in the 2017 to 2018 fiscal year ===
{| class="wikitable"
!Portfolio
!Regulations
!Publication date
!Exemption
type
|-
!Environment and Climate Change Canada
|''Regulations Amending Wild Animal and Plant Protection and Regulation of International and the Wild Animal and Plant Trade Regulations'' (SOR/2017-86)
|May 31, 2017
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Special Economic Measures (Syria) Regulations'' (SOR/2017-62)
|May 3, 2017
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Special Economic Measures (Syria) Regulations'' (SOR/2017-69)
|May 3, 2017
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Special Economic Measures (Venezuela) Regulations'' (SOR/2017-204)
|October 4, 2017
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Special Economic Measures (Venezuela) Permit Authorization Order'' (SOR/2017-205)
|October 4, 2017
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Justice for Victims of Corrupt Foreign Officials Regulations'' (SOR/2017-233)
|November 15, 2017
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Justice for Victims of Corrupt Foreign Officials Regulations'' (SOR/2018-25)
|March 7, 2018
|Emergency, unique or exceptional circumstances
|-
!Health Canada
|''Order Amending Schedules I and VI to the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (U-47700)'' (SOR/2017-277)
|December 27, 2017
|Non-discretionary obligations
|-
!Health Canada
|''Regulations Amending the Food and Drug Regulations and the Precursor Control Regulations (U-47700)'' (SOR/2017-278)
|December 27, 2017
|Non-discretionary obligations
|-
!Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada
|''Certificate of Supplementary Protection Regulations'' (SOR/2017-165)
|September 20, 2017
|Non-discretionary obligations
|}
== Appendix C: administrative burden count ==
=== Table C1: Administrative burden count by regulator, June 30, 2014, to June 30, 2017 ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
! rowspan="2" |Department or agency
! colspan="2" |2014
! colspan="2" |2015
! colspan="2" |2016
! colspan="2" |2017
|-
!Number
of
requirements
!Number
of
regulations
!Number
of
requirements
!Number
of
regulations
!Number
of
requirements
!Number
of
regulations
!Number
of
requirements
!Number
of
regulations
|-
!Indian and Northern Affairs Canada
|288
|12
|288
|11
|288
|11
|288
|12
|-
!Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
|134
|4
|134
|4
|133
|4
|133
|4
|-
!Canada Border Services Agency
|1,426
|30
|1,470
|30
|1,473
|30
|1,473
|30
|-
!Canada Revenue Agency
|1,776
|30
|1,776
|30
|1,807
|31
|1,807
|30
|-
!Canadian Dairy Commission
|4
|2
|4
|2
|4
|2
|4
|2
|-
!Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency
|89
|1
|89
|1
|89
|1
|89
|1
|-
!Canadian Food Inspection Agency
|10,989
|34
|11,021
|13
|11,880
|23
|12,047
|21
|-
!Canadian Grain Commission
|1,056
|1
|1,056
|1
|1,056
|1
|1,056
|1
|-
!Canadian Heritage
|797
|3
|798
|3
|802
|3
|802
|3
|-
!Canadian Intellectual Property Office
|569
|6
|568
|6
|568
|6
|568
|6
|-
!Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission
|8,169
|10
|8,169
|10
|8,169
|10
|8,169
|10
|-
!Canadian Pari-Mutuel Agency
|731
|2
|731
|2
|731
|2
|731
|2
|-
!Canadian Transportation Agency
|545
|7
|545
|7
|545
|7
|545
|7
|-
!Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada
|14
|1
|73
|1
|59
|1
|59
|1
|-
!Competition Bureau
|444
|3
|444
|3
|444
|3
|444
|3
|-
!Copyright Board Canada
|16
|1
|16
|1
|17
|1
|17
|1
|-
!Employment and Social Development Canada
|2,791
|7
|3,256
|7
|3,104
|7
|3,100
|6
|-
!Environment Canada and Climate Change Canada
|9,985
|53
|10,099
|53
|11,500
|53
|11,515
|52
|-
!Farm Products Council of Canada
|47
|3
|47
|3
|47
|3
|47
|3
|-
!Department of Finance Canada
|1,818
|42
|1,891
|42
|1,919
|42
|1,928
|42
|-
!Fisheries and Oceans Canada
|5,350
|30
|5,350
|31
|5,446
|31
|5,367
|30
|-
!Global Affairs Canada
|2,809
|55
|2,820
|58
|2,784
|57
|2,774
|56
|-
!Health Canada
|15,649
|95
|15,945
|32
|15,627
|31
|15,283
|31
|-
!Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada
|1,693
|8
|1,904
|8
|1,330
|7
|1,332
|7
|-
!Labour Program
|21,468
|32
|21,468
|17
|21,791
|17
|21,791
|17
|-
!Measurement Canada
|335
|2
|359
|2
|359
|2
|359
|2
|-
!National Energy Board
|1,298
|14
|1,298
|14
|4,012
|13
|4,012
|13
|-
!Natural Resources Canada
|4,507
|28
|4,507
|28
|4,507
|28
|4,432
|28
|-
!Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy
|799
|4
|799
|3
|799
|3
|799
|3
|-
!Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutionstable C1 notea
|2,875
|33
|2,875
|33
|2,899
|33
|2,586
|23
|-
!Parks Canada
|773
|25
|773
|25
|773
|25
|773
|25
|-
!Patented Medicine Prices Review Board
|59
|1
|59
|1
|59
|1
|59
|1
|-
!Public Health Agency of Canada
|42
|2
|42
|2
|173
|2
|189
|2
|-
!Public Safety Canada
|229
|6
|229
|6
|229
|6
|229
|6
|-
!Public Services and Procurement Canada
|388
|1
|388
|1
|493
|1
|498
|1
|-
!Statistics Canada
|157
|1
|157
|1
|157
|1
|157
|1
|-
!Transport Canada
|29,695
|94
|30,258
|94
|30,458
|98
|30,611
|95
|-
!Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat
|46
|1
|48
|2
|48
|2
|48
|2
|-
!Grand total
|129,860
|684
|131,754
|588
|136,579
|599
|136,121
|580
|-
! colspan="9" |
|-
| colspan="8" |a. The 2017 figure for the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions decreased by 313 requirements, related mainly to the removal from the count of 10 regulations that were considered to have been outside of the scope of the ABB.
!
|}
== Footnotes ==
